Banning Plastic Bags

Plastic bags

Banning plastic bags will not help the environment as much as its advocates say. New York is the latest state to ban single use plastic bags.

The problem is that the ban will not really do what the politicians and environmentalists make you think it will. Here is some very interesting information from the World Resources Institute, “Unfortunately, while these laws may reduce the most visible form of plastic pollution, it could be at the expense of other environmental impacts. That’s because, somewhat ironically, disposable plastic bags require fewer resources (land, water, CO2 emissions, etc.) to produce than paper, cotton or reusable plastic bags—by a wide margin.

For example, Denmark’s Ministry of Environment and Food found that you would need to reuse a paper bag at least 43 times for its per-use environmental impacts to be equal to or less than that of a typical disposable plastic bag used one time. An organic cotton bag must be reused 20,000 times to produce less of an environmental impact than a single-use plastic bag. That would be like using a cotton bag every day for nearly 55 years. (Note that these figures aggregate the bags’ impact on water use, CO2 emissions, land use and more, but they do not include their impact on plastic pollution.)

That is not to say that the plastic bag ban will remove the threat to wildlife, be it in the oceans or the land. But what is missing is the education component and it is a very important one. Of course the politicians have money on their minds. For example here is what New York passed (per CBS News), “most single-use plastic bags provided by supermarkets and other stores will be banned statewide starting March 1, 2020. Individual counties will have the option of charging 5 cents for paper bags, with 2 cents going to local governments and 3 cents to the state’s Environmental Protection Fund.” In other words the money component is more important then the environmental one, for you and I know that any monies collected will not go towards the aforementioned fund.

From Displayr, “Various alternatives to LDPE (single use) plastic bags are in use. One solution is for retailers to charge a small fee for a high-density polyethylene bag – a more durable plastic bag intended for reuse. Most supermarkets also offer ‘green’ bags and encourage customers to bring their own bags. These measures are intended to reduce the impact we have on the environment. But studies have shown that it actually takes more resources to manufacture alternatives to single-use bags! Potentially this could have a greater impact on the environment.

I must conclude that replacing single-use plastic bags with either so called ‘green’ bags or canvas (/cotton) bags is not the answer. As both are not any more environmentally friendly and are next to impossible to clean. Paper bags actually are more polluting to make although they will breakdown in a short amount of time.

What is needed is a combination of public education and environmental inventiveness. Only time will tell what the answer will be.

That is my opinion- Jumpin Jersey Mike

4/3/19-

Here is an article by CBS News that talks about a new way of recycling plastics that sounds very promising.

 

 

(Visited 32 times, 1 visits today)